Ann Mahony Home

Programs and Speeches
Legal/Forensic
Handwriting and Personality
Articles
Products and Services
Nuggets of Wisdom
What's HOT!
Contact Us

The Perils of Poor Customer Service
?
or How the Cookie Crumbles in Cyberspace?

Ah, the web. I can now talk to anyone, anytime, anywhere in the world. Recently, a friend from Oklahoma forwarded the following anonymous story, which stopped me cold. It wasn?t so much the story itself, but the speed at which the damage multiplied that reminded me again of the power of the web. The tale:

My daughter & I had just finished lunch at Neiman-Marcus Cafe in Dallas, and decided to splurge on dessert, ordering a scrumptious Neiman-Marcus cookie. It was so delicious, I asked if I could have the recipe. The waitress frowned and said, "I'm afraid I can't."
"Well, would you let me buy the recipe?" I asked.
She smiled and replied "Certainly."
"How much?" I inquired.
"Only two fifty." She told me. " It's a great deal!"
"Please add it to my tab" I told her.

When I received my statement at the end of the month, in addition to our two salads and the scarf I had purchased was an entry which read: Cookie Recipe - $250.00!! I was flabbergasted. I called Neiman's Accounting Dept. "The waitress said it was two-fifty. Clearly she didn?t mean two hundred and fifty dollars!" I told them. Neiman-Marcus refused to budge. They would not refund my money, because according to them, "You?ve already seen the recipe. We cannot refund your money at this point."

I was livid. I told them I would see to it that every cookie lover I could find would receive their recipe for free. The woman in accounting replied, "I wish you wouldn't do this."

"Well, you should have thought of that before you ripped me off," I told her, and hung up.

"So here it is!" the story continued, "Please pass it on to everyone you know. I don't want Neiman-Marcus to ever get another penny off of this recipe.... This is not a joke --- this is a true story."

First Response ? Skeptical but Curious
Surely there must be some mistake. I've never received anything less than thoroughly professional and courteous treatment from Neiman-Marcus. Since I speak about customer service to corporations and associations, however, I had to check it out. I e-mailed friends in Ardmore, Dallas, Houston, Tulsa, and Muskogee. Apparently I was the only one who hadn?t heard this story. It had circulated years before e-mail even existed. One friend, a doctor, said it had circulated around the hospital, and by the way, she added, did I know that the incident happened to a doctor, because "they always try to overcharge us." See what can happen when rumors run wild? Although many had heard the story,
no one could cite the source, or verify the veracity of the tale.

Is the Story True?
Does it matter? The damage has been done. In business, perception is everything. Few of us can boast Neiman?s 90+ year history of outstanding customer service to counterbalance any bad press. (For the record, I called Neiman-Marcus in Dallas and checked with Customer Service, Public Relations and
top management. Indeed, all departments were well aware of the story, assured me there wasn?t a grain of truth in it, and had no idea how it had originated.)

Lesson #1
True or not, the story holds a great lesson. Your first response to a customer?s complaint is the one
he will broadcast in cyberspace. The initial handling of your customer could seal the fate of your business. Every single person on your front line must understand this, or prepare for suicide watch.

Don?t we all make mistakes?
The copy shop bungles your job. The dry cleaner loses your favorite suit. You tell all your cronies avoid the place. If later, they manage to fix the problem, do you honestly take the time to call all your buddies to tell them "The problem has been handled. Really, they?re not so bad." A few years ago, a satisfied customer would tell two to three other people about your business, a dissatisfied customer would tell eight to ten. But that was before cyberspace.

Wildfire on the Web
You now have the power at your fingertips to spread the word like wildfire worldwide. That idea alone imbues some folks with a sense of unprecedented power. When Joe Average Customer (the true source of your paycheck) feels he?s being ignored, he may resort in frustration to - SHOUTING. Short of appearing on a prime time newscast, the web is the next best transmitter. Today, before you have the opportunity to rectify a misunderstanding with a customer, remove a surly employee, retrain the front line in telephone skills, it may already be too? late?

Smart Cookie
Now when you think of cookies, you may think Toll House, Mrs. Fields, etc., but I think fondly of Doubletree Resorts. They always give me a warm chocolate chip cookie upon check-in at any of
their establishments. Not just a cookie, a warm cookie. Talk about attention to detail. Sure it would be easier for them to keep them in a box, instead of continually refilling the warming bin, but the cookies aren?t there for the management?s convenience, they?re there for mine. I did a little sleuthing and discovered that in wintertime, businessmen frequently request a second cookie at bedtime. They may sound sheepish or embarrassed, but they do ask. Some even offer to pay for it. Are you listening? A service that?s so appreciated, people offer to pay for what the hotel will provide for free. Doubletree did their homework. We?re not talking cookies here, we?re talking customer satisfaction.

Recently, when Doubletree Resorts was mentioned briefly in a conversation on Rosie O?Donnell?s show, she couldn?t help but interject "They always leave a cookie on my pillow. I love those guys." Wow ? an unsolicited celebrity endorsement. Doubletree gets it.

I?m willing to bet that even if Doubletree makes a mistake on your bill, (which they can rectify) what you?ll remember about your stay is the friendly bellboy braving an icy sidewalk to deliver your second cookie.

Extra Care
Take a look next time you?re in a Doubletree room. Next to the telephone is a sign "CARE LINE 48. Doubletree is committed to providing our guests with outstanding service. Simply touch 48 on your phone with any special need or concern. You?ll get immediate action!" The sign is prominently displayed. They want to hear from me. I won?t abuse their offer with some trivial gripe.

Rather than directing me to a complaint department, they provide someone who cares about my needs. Sure, it may be clever marketing, but what about the employee who?s in charge of Care? The word alone helps set the tone for his/her frame of mind. And what about the customer? Even if you?re truly upset about something, what kind of cad would pick up the phone and yell at the Care Lady?

Fortify your front line
But I digress. Back to our cookie bellboy - you may be thinking, well hey, that?s how the front desk is supposed to respond. At the risk of stating the obvious ? everyone in your company is a front line person. Think about the Neiman-Marcus debacle. More accounting departments do more damage than the CEO will ever know. They?re not considered to be, nor trained to be front line people. Yet, when does accounting interface with the public? When there?s a question (translation: problem) regarding the bill. Think about it. How would you like every single piece of paper you produce to be scrutinized like a hotel bill?

Moreover, with department stores, hotels, etc. the invoice charges are entered from a variety of departments. Your bill is a collaborative effort, but only one department takes the heat. Perhaps you should (humorously) rename the department Collaborative Accounting Department. Find ways to let billing know you?re aware of the challenges they face, that it takes superior people to be up to the task, then train them accordingly.

Of course, it isn?t just accounting. Many departments considered to be "support" also interface with the public. If so, they need to be trained as front line people.

Let?s Play Pass the Buck
Bouncing an unhappy customer from department to department, like a basketball in a Chicago Bulls? game can drive him in frustration to the web. Why? It?s an instant release valve, literally at his fingertips. It?s particularly useful at midnight, when the customer is still fuming, but the "department" is closed. Even at 3:00 a.m., someone in cyberspace is always there to listen. The 24/7 power of the web allows customers to unload round the clock?and worldwide. Now that?s power. Turn it to your advantage.

Faster than a speeding bullet?it?s Super Service
Post a Customer Care Button on your web site, giving clients a venue to vent their frustrations to your first, so you?ll have a chance put the brakes on the broadcast. Hire a night owl (who can do the job from home) to download customer complaints and forward them to the right party. More importantly, your troubleshooter can simultaneously e-mail the unhappy customer to let him know someone is working on the problem. One tiny e-mail can blow out the match before the brushfire begins.

Can I have the recipe?
Now, whenever I include the cookie story in my customer care program, inevitably someone approaches me afterward asking "Can I have that cookie recipe?" I used to mentally slap my forehead and wonder "Weren?t they listening? I was talking about customer service!" Now I routinely supply not only a copy of the recipe, but a cookie for every audience member, explaining that I want them to see, touch, smell and taste the story to help them remember it.

We live in a society where the average attention span is eight minutes long ? the average time between television commercials. In this age of multi-media, you may need multiple methods to drive your message home.

Chips of Wisdom
Your first response to a customer?s complaint is the one he will broadcast in cyberspace.
  Answer wisely. The world is listening.

*A Complaint Is A Gift, Janelle Barlow.

NEIMAN MARCUS COOKIES
(Recipe may be halved)
2 cups butter
4 cups flour
2 tsp. soda
2 cups sugar
5 cups blended oatmeal ***
24 oz. chocolate chips
2 cups brown sugar
1 tsp. salt
1 8 oz. Hershey Bar (grated)
4 eggs
2 tsp. baking powder
2 tsp. vanilla
3 cups chopped nuts (your choice)

** Measure oatmeal and blend in a blender to a fine powder.

Cream the butter and both sugars. Add eggs and vanilla; mix together with flour, oatmeal, salt, baking powder, and soda. Add chocolate chips, Hershey Bar and nuts. Roll into balls and place two inches apart on a cookie sheet. Bake for 10 minutes at 375 degrees. Makes 112 cookies.

Back to Articles


About Ann Mahony
Speaker and author Ann Mahony addresses audiences nationwide on how to Lead From Your Strengths and Stay Connected in today's downsized, fast forward world.  Featured on ABC, NBC, CBS and CNN, she is the author of Handwriting & Personality...

We offer this article on a non-exclusive basis.  You may reprint or repost this material as long as Ann Mahony's name and contact information is included:

ANN MAHONY 
San Francisco --  P.O. Box 475166  .  San Francisco, CA 94147
Phone:  415/441-0273  .  Fax:  415/441-0233
Toll Free:  800/370-4010 

e-mail: ann@annmahony.com 

? 2000-2004 Ann Mahony